Frewsburg Real Estate | Frewsburg Homes for Sale

Property is on right hand side leaving Frewsburg. This secluded cabin, tucked away in beautiful green surrounding awaits it's new owner. Cabin built in 2024 and with care, it includes a back deck that over looks out over 2 acres and is perfect for weekend getaways or eve a full time home! Brand new metal roof, electric work that was just done. It boasts an open floor plan downstairs and a large open bedroom upstairs. Great wild life and plenty of things to don in the surrounding areas. Wood stove. NO Well or Septic.

12355 Bone Run Road, South Valley

$265,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ R1697338 MLS

Welcome to **44 Valley View Drive**! This spacious 5-bedroom, 3-bath raised ranch offers a versatile layout with room for everyone. The main level features an open-concept living room, dining area, and kitchen, creating a bright and inviting space for everyday living and entertaining. The primary suite includes a private en-suite bath, while two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom complete the upper level. The finished lower level provides exceptional flexibility with two additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a comfortable family room—perfect for guests, extended family, a home office, or additional recreational space. Step outside and enjoy multiple outdoor living areas, including a welcoming covered front porch, a spacious back patio, and a raised covered rear porch overlooking the backyard—ideal for relaxing or entertaining in any season. A blacktop circular driveway provides convenient access and ample parking, while the detached 2.5-car garage offers plenty of room for vehicles, storage, or a workshop. Situated on **three parcels totaling approximately 1.58 acres**, this property offers an abundance of outdoor space with endless possibilities for recreation, gardening, future expansion, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings. With generous living space, a flexible floor plan, and an incredible outdoor setting, this Frewsburg home is ready for its next owners to make it their own!

44 Valley View Drive, Carroll

$224,900

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1698786 MLS

Cute and cozy three-bedroom ranch home in the ‘burg. This home is tucked away on a side street and is within walking distance of both schools and dining options. Inside, practicality and comfort abound with single-level living. The main entry point is through the front door and into the living room, which features a bay window that looks out into the front yard. Just off the living room is the formal dining room with sliding glass doors into the three-seasons room. The three-seasons room looks out over the back yard, the exposed beams give the room an expansive and grand feel, this room will be your favorite place to watch the seasons change. The eat-in kitchen has plenty of storage space, including a clever built-in bread box and a pantry cupboard. The room is spacious enough to add in a small dining table or a breakfast nook. The home has a total of three bedrooms, all offering closet space. The full basement is partially finished, with a bar room to expand your options for hosting. The basement also has a workshop space with multiple surfaces to support a project of nearly any scale. The home has an attached one-car garage, and there is also a shed in the backyard to store your lawn care equipment. The back yard is currently lush with summer greenery, and there is an almost-hidden pergola just behind the house, imagine adding a seating area here, it would be your favorite place to relax after a long day.

4 E Meadow Lane, Carroll

$249,900

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697624 MLS

Exquisite contemporary ranch home in Frewsburg. Inside, the home features single-level living with a total of four bedrooms and two full baths on the primary floor. The galley-style kitchen is thoughtfully laid out with bright natural light from the skylight. The living room has a fireplace with stone masonry and a tastefully vibrant, but relaxing color palette. The formal dining room is located between the kitchen and the living room, providing a natural flow for entertaining. The primary bedroom has an ensuite bath and a generous closet. The basement is partially finished and does have an egress door. The finished part of the basement serves as a recreation space, but would also work as a home gym or a game room, perfect for entertaining. There is a bonus storage room in the basement. Outside, the home has a two-car carport, and the backyard has a patio for enjoying the temperate weather. There is a shed to store lawn care equipment, and there are planters for the aspiring gardener. This unique home has many upgrades, including central A/C, a radon mitigation system, and a water softener, adding value and comfort to an already attractive property.

16 Mattison Street, Carroll

$99,900

R1698358 MLS

Beautiful land in Frewsburg. Great place to build a dream home, agricultural use or development. Panoramic country views. Zoned agriculture residential so many possible uses. Not too far out but gives the feel of complete peace and privacy. There was once a home here so utilities are nearby. The driveway still exists as well. The homes foundation is still there with a possibility to be utilized. Additional acreage available, see MLS number R1674762 for details to purchase in its entirety.

1004 Wigren Road, Carroll

$194,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1697610 MLS

Spacious home on a generous 3/4-acre lot in the heart of Frewsburg. Set on a gorgeous tree-lined lot, this home captures the feeling of country living right in the cozy suburbs. On the back of the house is an oversized family room that would be great for entertaining. Inside, the main floor features a formal dining room and a roomy eat-in, country kitchen offering clever hidden storage drawers in the baseboards and a fireplace. The living room also has a fireplace, built-in storage, and recessed lighting. The family room features another fireplace and baseboard heat, but also banks of windows that look out over the backyard, bringing in natural light and a touch of the outdoors. There is a first-floor bedroom that could also serve as an office or hobby space. The main floor offers a full bath and a convenient laundry room. Upstairs, there is another full bath and two more bedrooms. The primary bedroom has two large walk-in closets. One of the closets shares a wall with the other bedroom, and that wall could potentially be removed to split the other bedroom into two. The home is equipped with central A/C and forced air heat for year-round comfort. Outside, the detached garage has three work bays and workshop space available. PLEASE LOOK AT THE ADDITIONAL SELLER INFO SHEET for updates to the property.

62 Ivory Street, Carroll

$224,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1695363 MLS

Escape to the peace and privacy of country living in this beautifully updated three-bedroom, one-bath home situated on two scenic acres and conveniently located near South Valley State Forest and Onoville Marina, making it an ideal retreat for outdoor enthusiasts. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan featuring a modern kitchen with a center island and breakfast bar, perfect for gatherings and everyday convenience. The spacious great room boasts stunning tongue-and-groove ceilings and a centrally located wood-burning stove that efficiently distributes warmth throughout the home, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The updated bathroom offers a touch of luxury with a double vanity and an oversized walk-in tile shower. Need extra space? The integral one-car garage includes a versatile rec room or potential third bedroom above, complete with its own private deck. The main level of the home also features a spacious laundry room with plenty of cabinets and counter space. Outside, you'll find plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, and storage with the attached two-car garage/storage area. Relax and entertain on the expansive covered front porch, an exceptional outdoor living space featuring its own fireplace—perfect for enjoying crisp evenings year-round. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a property close to hunting, hiking, and recreation, this charming home offers the perfect blend of modern updates, comfort, and country appeal. Also listed under MLS #R1694493.

12751 Sawmill Run Road, South Valley

$224,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ R1694493 MLS

Escape to the peace and privacy of country living in this beautifully updated three-bedroom, one-bath home situated on two scenic acres and conveniently located near South Valley State Forest and Onoville Marina, making it an ideal retreat for outdoor enthusiasts. Step inside to an inviting open floor plan featuring a modern kitchen with a center island and breakfast bar, perfect for gatherings and everyday convenience. The spacious great room boasts stunning tongue-and-groove ceilings and a centrally located wood-burning stove that efficiently distributes warmth throughout the home, creating a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The updated bathroom offers a touch of luxury with a double vanity and an oversized walk-in tile shower. Need extra space? The integral one-car garage includes a versatile rec room or potential third bedroom above, complete with its own private deck. The main level of the home also features a spacious laundry room with plenty of cabinets and counter space. Outside, you'll find plenty of room for vehicles, hobbies, and storage with the attached two-car garage/storage area. Relax and entertain on the expansive covered front porch, an exceptional outdoor living space featuring its own fireplace—perfect for enjoying crisp evenings year-round. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, a weekend getaway, or a property close to hunting, hiking, and recreation, this charming home offers the perfect blend of modern updates, comfort, and country appeal. Also listed under MLS #R1695363.

12751 Sawmill Run Road, South Valley

$274,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1691398 MLS

Move-in ready three-bedroom ranch in the ‘burg! Set on a side street off Ivory, this home is in the heart of Frewsburg. The schools are within walking distance, along with the public library and various dining options. The home is heated with hot-water baseboard heat and also has a separate forced-air Central A/C system. Inside, the home has a spacious living room with a wood-burning fireplace, a built-in curio cabinet, and a large picture window bringing in warm, natural light. The eat-in kitchen has a breakfast bar and a pantry, with space to add a small dining table or a breakfast nook. The formal dining room features French doors onto the patio for seamless entertaining. The primary bedroom is large, with two closets and an en-suite bath. The full basement is partially finished, there is a spacious recreation room with a bar and a second wood-burning fireplace, such a great space for entertaining guests! The unfinished part of the basement offers more storage space and workshop space. Outside, the home has an attached two-car garage with water service. The home is set on a double lot, giving you plenty of space to plant a garden or host summertime barbecues. The current owner has just put on a new roof, and a brand-new septic system will be installed prior to closing. List agent is related to seller.

10 Durand Street, Carroll

$365,000

R1691933 MLS

This property is loaded with potential. The iconic “Smiley-Face” barn is well-known locally when entering Frewsburg from the west. The smiling sunshine is a constant reminder of brighter days ahead, including owning this local legend. The barn sits on the road front 2-3 acres which is currently zoned as part of the business district. Thus, the front acres can be further developed for business interests, adding value for the new owner. The barn has electric throughout both the main floor and second floor loft area. It is currently used as both equipment storage and workshop area. On the exterior, there is a leanto the length of the barn also used for outside storage of equipment. There is another equipment shed on the property further from the barn in the open field area also used for storage.The forested area is a combination of maple, cherry, hickory, beech, hemlock and other species that provide both food and cover for deer. The owner has constructed blinds in the best locations and has harvested many trophies over the years. He created some small food plots along the primary road into the woods which have been a magnet for deer over the years. The big bucks have the heavy protective cover of the brushy and swampy areas and come to food plots regularly. The plots have not been planted for this season. Frews Run is a full-time flowing stream that traverses the width of the property and is identified as a brown and rainbow trout stream by the State. There is also a gas well on the property and the current royalties are about $1,400/year. The lease also provides the opportunity for free gas, so if you want a remote cabin site for your hunting pleasure, you might want to locate near the gas well for this purpose. All rights will transfer. There is a wide open canvas of things you can do with this property given the business district in the front and another dozen or more acres of open and brush land behind that are ideally suited to home, camp or other construction. The barn, stream and gas well are a huge bonus along with fantastic hunting!

W Main Street, Carroll

$799,999

R1684509 MLS

Rare opportunity to own a beloved WNY landmark! The iconic Nic-L-Inn sits on 5.75 acres along Bone Run Road in South Valley, Cattaraugus County a rustic country inn nestled in the foothills of the Allegany Mountains, cherished by locals and visitors for decades. The building spans 5,000+ sq ft with three fieldstone fireplaces, a full commercial kitchen, and generous dining space. Outside, a covered patio with a bar and waterfall creates an unforgettable setting. All equipment and dining supplies included truly turnkey. Located just 4 miles from Onoville Marina on the 12,000-acre Allegheny Reservoir, surrounded by 4,227 acres of NYS public land, this property sits at the heart of the Southern Tier's finest four-season recreation. Bald eagles soar over 91 miles of pristine shoreline. Boaters, anglers, snowmobilers, skiers, and hunters pour through this area year-round and they all need a great place to eat and stay. A storied roadhouse on the main corridor between Jamestown and Bradford, this is your chance to write the next chapter. The Possibilities Are Endless: Restaurant & Bar Revival — Commercial kitchen, fireplaces, patio bar, and a loyal regional following. One of the most ready-to-reopen properties in WNY. Craft Brewery or Distillery — Open layout, commercial infrastructure, and a built-in destination crowd. Hunting & Fishing Lodge — Thousands of acres of NYS forest on all sides. World-class deer, turkey, and bear. Kinzua Reservoir out front. Wedding & Event Venue — Fieldstone fireplaces, waterfall patio, and sweeping natural surroundings. Few venues in the region compare. Bed & Breakfast or Boutique Inn — Skiers, snowmobilers, boaters, and hunters all need a place to stay. This is it. ATV & Snowmobile Destination — Food, lodging, and trail access in one location. Sells itself in South Valley. Private Residence or Family Compound — 5,000+ sq ft, multiple fireplaces, and thousands of acres of state forest as your backyard. Wellness Retreat — Wooded setting, water feature, hiking, horseback riding, and kayaking at your door. 100% turnkey opportunity. Everything is included!! See it today!

12045 Bone Run Road, South Valley

$799,999

R1684599 MLS

Rare opportunity to own a beloved WNY landmark! The iconic Nic-L-Inn sits on 5.75 acres along Bone Run Road in South Valley, Cattaraugus County a rustic country inn nestled in the foothills of the Allegany Mountains, cherished by locals and visitors for decades. The building spans 5,000+ sq ft with three fieldstone fireplaces, a full commercial kitchen, and generous dining space. Outside, a covered patio with a bar and waterfall creates an unforgettable setting. All equipment and dining supplies included truly turnkey. Located just 4 miles from Onoville Marina on the 12,000-acre Allegheny Reservoir, surrounded by 4,227 acres of NYS public land, this property sits at the heart of the Southern Tier's finest four-season recreation. Bald eagles soar over 91 miles of pristine shoreline. Boaters, anglers, snowmobilers, skiers, and hunters pour through this area year-round and they all need a great place to eat and stay. A storied roadhouse on the main corridor between Jamestown and Bradford, this is your chance to write the next chapter. The Possibilities Are Endless: Restaurant & Bar Revival Commercial kitchen, fireplaces, patio bar, and a loyal regional following. One of the most ready-to-reopen properties in WNY. Craft Brewery or Distillery — Open layout, commercial infrastructure, and a built-in destination crowd. Hunting & Fishing Lodge — Thousands of acres of NYS forest on all sides. World-class deer, turkey, and bear. Kinzua Reservoir out front. Wedding & Event Venue — Fieldstone fireplaces, waterfall patio, and sweeping natural surroundings. Few venues in the region compare. Bed & Breakfast or Boutique Inn — Skiers, snowmobilers, boaters, and hunters all need a place to stay. This is it. ATV & Snowmobile Destination Food, lodging, and trail access in one location. This property Sells itself in South Valley. Private Residence or Family Compound — 5,000+ sq ft, multiple fireplaces, and thousands of acres of state forest as your backyard. Wellness Retreat — Wooded setting, water feature, hiking, horseback riding, and kayaking at your door. 100% turnkey opportunity. Everything is included!! See it today!

12045 Bone Run Road, South Valley

$239,900

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1690678 MLS

Welcome home to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath Cape Cod located on a rare double lot in the Village of Frewsburg. Situated on approximately half an acre, this move-in ready home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and convenience. Numerous updates have already been completed, including a new driveway, metal roof, and vinyl windows, allowing the next owner to move right in and enjoy. The home features a full finished basement that provides excellent additional living space and flexibility for a family room, recreation area, home office, or guest accommodations. Outside, you’ll find a spacious 24’ x 36’ garage with an attached storage area that offers the potential to be finished for even more usable space. The backyard is designed for relaxation and entertaining, featuring a patio, fire pit, storage shed, and a private, secluded setting rarely found within the village. The generous lot size spans from Ivory to Danielson and Carroll Streets! With its updated condition, beautiful front porch, and abundance of indoor and outdoor living space, this property is a must-see. Schedule your private showing today!

76 Ivory Street, Carroll

$79,900

3 Beds ⋅ R1681877 MLS

UNIQUE BARN CONVERSION ON RURAL PROPERTY! Selling "AS IS," this one-of-a-kind property offers endless potential for renovation, recreation, storage, or a future homestead project. Located in the Frewsburg School District, the property includes a converted barn-style dwelling, detached barn, and insulated workshop in a quiet country setting. The converted barn dwelling offers approximately 1,370 square feet of space and features: • Enclosed porch • Large living room area • Kitchen area with pantry • 3 possible bedrooms • Entrance room with concrete floor • Large rear porch • Partial basement with standing water • Existing water well Please note: There is currently no electrical wiring in any of the buildings, including the dwelling, and there is no central heating system. Additional Structures Include: • 35’ x 35' • 12’ x 20’ insulated workshop

1106 Frew Run Road, Carroll

$194,500

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ R1678022 MLS

Sitting on 2.4 acres in the hills of Frewsburg, this idyllic home offers the peace and privacy so many buyers are searching for. Inside has a warm and woodsy cabin feel, highlighted by cathedral ceilings and a loft that overlooks the living space below. The spacious living room features durable tile flooring and is centered around a cozy wood stove. The eat-in kitchen opens to a porch, creating an easy transition to outdoor dining. Upstairs, you’ll find two bedrooms along with a versatile loft currently used as an office, but with potential for additional sleeping space if desired. With two full bathrooms and a functional layout, the home is well-suited for year-round living or a weekend retreat. There is also a second-story balcony that provides an elevated spot to take in the rolling hillside. The property also includes a barn/outbuilding with electric. It's currently used for storage, but offers potential.

256 Bragg Road, Carroll

Frewsburg Homes for Sale

Newest Frewsburg Homes for Sale