Cattaraugus Real Estate | Cattaraugus Homes for Sale

Located in the Village of Cattaraugus, this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home is full of potential and ready for its next chapter. Offering a functional layout with the convenience of first-floor laundry, this home provides a great opportunity for buyers looking to add their own style and build equity through cosmetic updates. Outside, you'll find an attached garage, a storage shed, and a spacious backyard that's perfect for entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the outdoors. Whether you're a first-time home buyer, investor, or someone looking for a home you can make your own, this property offers solid bones, a desirable village location, and endless possibilities.

65 South Street, New Albion

$175,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1699834 MLS

Welcome to 10044 Leon Road in Cattaraugus—a spacious 4-bedroom, 2-bath home full of timeless character, modern updates, and endless potential. From the moment you step inside, you'll appreciate the warmth of the natural hardwood floors, classic architectural details, and inviting spaces that make this house feel like home. Thoughtful updates throughout provide peace of mind while preserving the home's original charm, creating the perfect blend of old and new. With generous living spaces, four comfortable bedrooms, and two full bathrooms, there's plenty of room to grow, gather, and make lasting memories. Whether you're looking for a move-in-ready family home or a property with the opportunity to add your own personal touch over time, this one offers the best of both worlds. Conveniently located, you'll enjoy small-town charm with easy access to nearby amenities, schools, and outdoor recreation. Don't miss your chance to own a home where character, comfort, and potential come together.

10044 Leon Road, New Albion

$199,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1697823 MLS

Welcome to 6793 Snyder Hill Road, where peaceful country living meets everyday comfort. Nestled on 1.96 private acres, this well-maintained three bedroom, 1.5 bath home offers the perfect retreat for those looking to enjoy nature, privacy, and the beauty of the enchanted mountains of Western New York. The spacious kitchen features abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, and a large center island, making it ideal for everyday living and entertaining. All appliances are included, allowing for a seamless move-in experience. Step outside onto the deck and enjoy the tranquil wooded setting, where deer, turkey, bears, and other wildlife are frequent visitors. The property is a gardener’s delight with five mature blueberry bushes, along with established blackberry and raspberry bushes that provide fresh seasonal harvests. A unique bonus is the availability of hookups for three campers with two septic systems, offering exceptional flexibility for hosting family and friends or recreational use. Ideal for outdoor enthusiasts and entertaining, the property features outdoor access to electric, a separate septic system, three water hookups, and a large garage with RV space, water and sewer access. Recent updates include a new furnace (2018), new well pump switch (2021), new water heater (2021), new washer and dryer (2023), septic pumped (2024), and fresh interior and exterior paint (2025). Additional features include generous storage throughout the home, economical electric costs averaging approximately $120-$180 per month, a whole-house water shutoff for seasonal convenience, and the snowblower and lawn mower are included with the sale. Conveniently located just 20 minutes from Ellicottville and Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino and approximately 25 minutes from Allegany State Park, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a peaceful weekend getaway, or a place to gather with family and friends, this property is ready to welcome its next owners. Also listed as seasonal/camps, B1699167

6793 Snyder Hill Road, New Albion

$199,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1699167 MLS

Welcome to 6793 Snyder Hill Road, where peaceful country living meets everyday comfort. Nestled on 1.96 private acres, this well-maintained three bedroom, 1.5 bath home offers the perfect retreat for those looking to enjoy nature, privacy, and the beauty of the enchanted mountains of Western New York. The spacious kitchen features abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, and a large center island, making it ideal for everyday living and entertaining. All appliances are included, allowing for a seamless move-in experience. Step outside onto the deck and enjoy the tranquil wooded setting, where deer, turkey, bears, and other wildlife are frequent visitors. The property is a gardener’s delight with five mature blueberry bushes, along with established blackberry and raspberry bushes that provide fresh seasonal harvests. A unique bonus is the availability of hookups for three campers with two septic systems, offering exceptional flexibility for hosting family and friends or recreational use. Ideal for outdoor enthusiasts and entertaining, the property features outdoor access to electric, a separate septic system, three water hookups, and a large garage with RV space, water and sewer access. Recent updates include a new furnace (2018), new well pump switch (2021), new water heater (2021), new washer and dryer (2023), septic pumped (2024), and fresh interior and exterior paint (2025). Additional features include generous storage throughout the home, economical electric costs averaging approximately $120-$180 per month, a whole-house water shutoff for seasonal convenience, and the snowblower and lawn mower are included with the sale. Conveniently located just 20 minutes from Ellicottville and Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino and approximately 25 minutes from Allegany State Park, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a peaceful weekend getaway, or a place to gather with family and friends, this property is ready to welcome its next owners. Also listed as residential, B1697823.

6793 Snyder Hill Road, New Albion

$185,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1699399 MLS

Nothing to do but move in!! New everything except the siding, studs, foundation and rafters. All new windows, drywall, fiberglass insulation, metal roof, floor coverings, plumbing fixtures and appliances. Hardwood floor in the living\dining room, ceramic tile in the kitchen and bathrooms, laminate in the laundry room and rear sunporch and carpet upstairs. Extra deep back yard with a storage shed and firepit provide an outdoor space to enjoy in the warmer months and the low utility bills let you stay warm and cozy inside all winter. A quiet neighborhood location with low traffic makes this a great village spot with easy access to local amenties. High end stainless steel kitchen appliances are included which set off the granite counters and new kitchen cabinets perfectly! The high efficency boiler with indirect hot water heater keep gas bills low and Little Valley electric is very affordable. A great place to live in the Village of Little Valley!!!

103 9th Street, Little Valley

$399,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1695231 MLS

Your Next Masterpiece Begins Here. Hidden among the trees on 6.11 private acres, this beautifully renovated contemporary home offers the rare opportunity to live in what feels like a modern four-story treehouse. Designed to embrace its natural surroundings, the home is filled with dramatic windows, soaring views of the forest, and an abundance of natural light that pours into every level, creating an atmosphere that is both inspiring and peaceful. With over 2,300 square feet, 4 levels of living space, 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and thoughtful updates throughout, every floor offers its own unique experience. Multiple living areas provide endless flexibility for an artist studio, writer’s retreat, home office, music room, fitness space, or guest accommodations. The finished fourth floor has been transformed into additional living space, offering a private escape limited only by your imagination. Whether you’re entertaining friends, working remotely, or simply unwinding after a long day, every room is designed to connect you with nature. Expansive windows frame the changing seasons like living artwork, while the covered porch invites morning coffee, evening conversations, and quiet moments beneath the trees. A detached two-car garage provides additional storage, workshop potential, or space for outdoor recreation equipment. Conveniently located near Ellicottville, Holiday Valley, HoliMont, Allegany State Park, and the Southern Tier, this exceptional property is ideal as a luxury country home, vacation retreat, weekend escape, Airbnb investment, or full-time residence. More than just a house, this is a destination you’ll look forward to coming home to every single day—a place where the outside world fades away, creativity flourishes, and every season becomes part of the experience. Private. Renovated. Light-filled. One of a kind. Welcome home.

9121 Dake Hill Road, Otto

$75,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1695257 MLS

Attention DIYs, handymen, and investors! Offered for sale is this 4 bedroom (with a possible fifth) two and a half bath classic Victorian. This home needs some TLC but with the right vision can become your dream home. Vintage layout features large living room, dining room and kitchen all convenient to the huge covered porch. There are four bedrooms upstairs with a full bath on the master. Hardwood floors and old style moldings and woodwork throughout the house remind us of the elegance of a bygone era. All this on a generous sized lot in the picturesque Village of Cattaraugus.

97 Washington Street, New Albion

$749,500

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ B1693789 MLS

A Stunning Timber Frame Home with Luxury Finishes on 7.96 acres—No Detail Overlooked! Nestled in a private yet convenient setting, this exceptional home offers breathtaking views, spectacular sunsets, and scenic nature trails throughout this secluded community. Beautifully landscaped with a variety of plantings, including bamboo, an automated irrigation system, and a wraparound deck—partially covered—with a gas line for your barbecue, making outdoor living and entertaining effortless. Step inside to soaring ceilings and a dramatic wall of windows that flood the home with natural light, seamlessly blending the beauty of the outdoors with the warmth of the interior. The open-concept great room, dining area, and gourmet kitchen feature rich wood ceilings, engineered hardwood floors with radiant heat, and a stunning stone fireplace. The chef's kitchen is appointed with quartz countertops and premium appliances, including a Miele dishwasher, Bosch gas range and microwave, and a KitchenAid refrigerator A private hallway leads to a main-level bedroom with ensuite, an additional bedroom, full bath, and laundry. Upstairs, the open loft overlooks the great room and showcases beautiful views. Beyond the double doors, the expansive primary suite offers a spa-like bath and walk-in closet. The finished lower level features an oversized recreation room, an additional spacious bedroom with a walk-in closet, a full bath, and sliding glass doors leading outdoors. There is a detached 1 car garage with power and a workshop area. Combining exceptional craftsmanship, luxurious finishes, and an unforgettable setting, this remarkable home offers the perfect balance of elegance, comfort, and nature. A rare opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind retreat where every day feels like a getaway. Approximately 10 minutes to the slopes of Holimont and Holiday Valley. Located a short distance from Buffalo, Toronto, Cleveland and Pittsburgh”. Furnishings Negotiable.

8472 Bailey Hill Road Lot #11, East Otto

$659,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ B1686434 MLS

Nestled on more than 4 picturesque acres just minutes from the Village of Ellicottville, this stunning 3–4 bedroom chalet offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and modern updates. Surrounded by beautifully maintained grounds and a serene natural setting, this property is an ideal year-round residence, vacation retreat, or investment opportunity. Inside, you'll find an inviting open-concept floor plan designed for entertaining and everyday living. The fully updated kitchen features modern finishes and flows seamlessly into the spacious living and dining areas. The loft-level primary suite provides a private retreat with elevated views of the surrounding landscape. The finished walkout basement expands the living space with a wet bar/recreation room, and direct access to the outdoor hot tub—perfect for relaxing after a day on the slopes, golf course, or hiking trails. A three-car garage offers ample storage for vehicles, outdoor gear, and recreational equipment. Enjoy the peace and tranquility of country living while remaining conveniently close to all that Ellicottville has to offer, including skiing, golf, dining, shopping, and year-round events.

5996 Whig Street, Little Valley

$159,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ B1684398 MLS

Nestled within the Little Valley Rod & Gun Club, this charming, move-in ready, partially furnished, 2-bedroom, 1-bath cabin offers the perfect retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Step through the sliding glass doors from the spacious L-shaped side porch into a warm and inviting living room featuring vaulted ceilings and a cozy pellet stove. The open-concept layout flows seamlessly into the kitchen, with a charming breakfast nook nestled between the two spaces—an ideal spot for morning coffee or casual dining. Just off the breakfast nook is a versatile room that can function as a bedroom or home office, providing flexible space for guests, remote work, or hobbies. The cabin also features a cozy primary bedroom and a versatile loft, offering additional space for guests, recreation, or storage. Just off the second porch, a convenient laundry area provides the perfect spot to drop sandy towels and lake gear, making cleanup after a day on the water quick and easy. Outside, two storage sheds provide ample space for tools, outdoor equipment, lake toys, recreational gear, and seasonal items and the Golf Cart is included. The Club offers an exceptional collection of outdoor amenities designed for year-round recreation and family enjoyment. Set along a picturesque lake, residents can enjoy a sandy beach ideal for swimming, sunbathing, and kayaking. The waterfront also features a slide and diving board, providing fun for all ages. A playground offers endless entertainment for children, while the pavilion serves as the perfect gathering place for picnics, celebrations, or simply relaxing in the shade. Miles of scenic trails on 83 meander throughout the 83 common acres, offering excellent opportunities for hiking and 4-wheeling during the warmer months and snowmobiling in winter. Whether you seek outdoor adventure or peaceful relaxation, this setting delivers in every season. This charming, fully furnished cabin combines comfort, privacy, and lakeside living. Tucked away in a tranquil setting yet conveniently located just 10 minutes to Ellicottville and minutes from Holiday Valley skiing, golf, and year-round recreation. Open, Sat, 11-1pm.

5419 Narrows, Rod & Gun Club Road Unit 36, Napoli

$138,800

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1689857 MLS

Completely updated and move-in ready, this furnished 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers affordable living, modern comforts, and an outstanding location just minutes from Ellicottville's four-season attractions. Less than 10 minutes from Holiday Valley and HoliMont, this property is ideal as a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or investment property for ski and outdoor enthusiasts. Extensive improvements completed within the last two years include a newer metal roof and siding, a stunning 10' x 26' primary bedroom addition with a private full bath, new flooring throughout, beautiful tongue-and-groove wood walls, updated landscaping, and two inviting porches perfect for enjoying the peaceful surroundings. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of room for dining and includes a convenient laundry area, while an additional storage room provides space for a freezer, second refrigerator, or extra gear storage. The comfortable living room features a freestanding gas fireplace, creating the perfect gathering space after a day on the slopes. Energy-efficient electric service through Little Valley Electric and on-demand hot water help keep utility costs low. Offered fully furnished with most furnishings purchased new, including a brand-new pullout sofa, the home comfortably sleeps up to eight guests. Outside, you'll find a beautifully maintained lot and a generous 12' x 20' storage building for recreational equipment, tools, or seasonal storage. Conveniently located near skiing, Seneca Allegany Resort & Casino, dining, and shopping, this property offers exceptional value with virtually all the major work already completed. Simply move in, unpack, and start enjoying everything ski country living has to offer.

5491 Route 353, Little Valley

$995,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1680910 MLS

Take advantage of this rare opportunity to acquire a well-established and highly regarded small engine repair business together with the real estate. For more than 40 years, Ray’s Small Engine Repair has proudly served WNY. This turnkey operation offers a diverse range of services, equipment maintenance and repair, new and pre-owned mower sales, equipment rentals, parts sales, and OEM parts distribution. An authorized dealer for Ariens, Gravely, and ECHO products and provides service for many leading brands, including Husqvarna, Stihl, Toro, John Deere, and others. The sale includes the fully equipped business operation, real estate, inventory, fixtures and equipment, business name, phone number, customer database. The property features multiple service bays, and extensive storage space, including a 40' x 120' retail and service building with 12-foot ceilings and a large office area on the second level. An additional 40' x 100' barn provides substantial storage and operational flexibility and features a recently installed roof. Also included is a well-maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod home situated adjacent to the business. Overlooking a scenic pond from the rear porch, the residence offers a peaceful setting while providing the convenience of a true live-work lifestyle. The home features four bedrooms and 2.5 baths. The living room is highlighted by a large bay window. The spacious kitchen offers ample cabinetry, and a butcher block countertop. It boasts a separate home office with a door to the back deck. Beyond its current use, this versatile property offers a wide range of potential future uses. With expansive buildings, open land, and a scenic pond setting, the property may lend itself to a variety of agricultural, recreational, or hobby-farm opportunities. Buyers may wish to explore the potential for equestrian use, including a horse farm. The combination of commercial facilities, residential accommodations, and ample outdoor space creates endless possibilities with room to grow and adapt to their vision. Open House, Sat., 6/13, 11-1pm.

9511 Utley Road, East Otto

$995,000

B1677207 MLS

Take advantage of this rare opportunity to acquire a well-established and highly regarded small engine repair business together with the real estate. For more than 40 years, Ray’s Small Engine Repair has proudly served WNY. This turnkey operation offers a diverse range of services, equipment maintenance and repair, new and pre-owned mower sales, equipment rentals, parts sales, and OEM parts distribution. An authorized dealer for Ariens, Gravely, and ECHO products and provides service for many leading brands, including Husqvarna, Stihl, Toro, John Deere, and others. The sale includes the fully equipped business operation, real estate, inventory, fixtures and equipment, business name, phone number, customer database. The property features multiple service bays, and extensive storage space, including a 40' x 120' retail and service building with 12-foot ceilings and a large office area on the second level. An additional 40' x 100' barn provides substantial storage and operational flexibility and features a recently installed roof. Also included is a well-maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Cape Cod home situated adjacent to the business. Overlooking a scenic pond from the rear porch, the residence offers a peaceful setting while providing the convenience of a true live-work lifestyle. The home features four bedrooms and 2.5 baths. The living room is highlighted by a large bay window. The spacious kitchen offers ample cabinetry, and a butcher block countertop. It boasts a separate home office with a door to the back deck. Beyond its current use, this versatile property offers a wide range of potential future uses. With expansive buildings, open land, and a scenic pond setting, the property may lend itself to a variety of agricultural, recreational, or hobby-farm opportunities. Buyers may wish to explore the potential for equestrian use, including a horse farm. The combination of commercial facilities, residential accommodations, and ample outdoor space creates endless possibilities with room to grow and adapt to their vision. Open House, Sat., 6/13,‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌ 11-1pm.

9511 Utley Road, East Otto

$189,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1689791 MLS

NEW PRICE!!! This extraordinary 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect mix of comfort, function, and peaceful outdoor living! This home is a true Cinderella story, with a remarkable transformation from 2021 to 2026 that shines from the moment you arrive! The first floor features a wonderful, easy-flowing layout with an open kitchen, breakfast bar, and dining area, plus a dedicated kids’ toy room that wraps around to the living room for everyday convenience. A huge bonus room doubles as a laundry area, home gym, storage space, hobby room, or whatever fits your lifestyle, while the first-floor bathroom is an added bonus. Upstairs, the spacious primary bedroom offers its own ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet, with two additional bedrooms completing the second floor. Outside is where this property really feels special, with a park-like setting, spacious deck, playset area, room for BBQs and gatherings, and a peaceful pathway leading down to the creek (sellers ARE NOT required to carry flood insurance)! The detached 2-car garage with lean-to provides excellent space for vehicles, lawn equipment, gardening tools, and outdoor toys. With super affordable taxes, municipal utilities, and a central location close to Ellicottville, Salamanca, Allegany State Park, and Randolph, this move-in ready home is an incredible opportunity to enjoy space, updates, and small-town charm all in one!

112 Mill Street, Little Valley

$149,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ B1683703 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully remodeled home updated from top to bottom, inside and out! The first floor offers a spacious living room filled with natural light, a formal dining room perfect for holiday gatherings, and a large kitchen with plenty of cabinetry and workspace for preparing your favorite meals. A convenient first-floor laundry area and full bathroom add everyday practicality, while the second story features three bedrooms and an additional full bathroom. The oversized primary bedroom offers incredible flexibility and could easily function as a private retreat, studio-style suite, hobby space, or spacious home office. The property is being subdivided from a larger parcel, with the final lot size expected to be approximately 0.50 to 0.75 acres. Updated taxes will be determined once the subdivision is complete. Offers are subject to the town's approval of the proposed subdivision. Conveniently located between the Village of Cattaraugus and Little Valley, this move-in-ready home offers modern updates, comfortable living space, and a great rural setting with easy access to nearby amenities.

6829 Nys Route 353, New Albion

Cattaraugus Homes for Sale

Newest Cattaraugus Homes for Sale